Throughout church history, many women have been advised to stay with their husbands by ministers, even though the minister knows that her husband has been abusing her. I am not referring to all ministers but there are clearly many who do. These ministers believe they are sincerely doing the right thing. They believe the Bible ordains it and they have many Scriptures to back it up. They sincerely believe they are doing the right thing and convince the woman to stay with her husband on Biblical grounds; however, they are sincerely wrong!
When we talk about men abusing their wives (there are also women who abuse their husbands) we are talking about domestic violence. Some research studies report that 40% of all police officers are injured, and 20% of all police officers are killed responding to domestic violence.
Spousal abuse is very serious and the average minister has no professional training in this area. They are in every way, over their head, and placing the abused spouse in harms way.
Clinical psychologists, psychiatrists, and psychiatric social workers have specialized training in this area. As soon as it is revealed that there is sufficient evidence to suspect violence in the marriage, marriage counseling is over. If they are to be seen for counseling, it will need to be individual counseling. It is simply too dangerous. If the couple is seen in marital counseling and the abuser hears her say something he doesn't like, she will be subject to his anger after the session is over.
Years ago I conducted 12 session workshops for male abusers who were referred by the State of Ohio. It would take roughly four sessions just to get the abusers to examine their denial system. For example, it was not unusual for the man to say, "It's her fault . . . if she would keep her mouth shut . . ." I remember one man who felt he was being railroaded in taking the workshop (they had to pay for it out of their own pockets) who refused to take any responsibility for his actions and denied any wrongdoing whatsoever. I had his police papers in front of me and when I pointed out that he hit his wife in the face so hard it required extensive plastic surgery, he was still in denial blaming her for everything that happened.
In those days it was called impulse control therapy, today it is called anger management. In emotionally charged situations, abusers can be very violent. Imagine what it would be like if you had a violent dog living in your home and you had to be very careful of everything you did, so you didn't get attacked. Many women subject to abuse describe their marriage this way.
Imagine if you will, a Christian woman who is completely torn as to what to do. She wants to do the right thing, but what is the right thing? Who do you listen to? Will the church help or hurt you? Who do you trust? Do you even trust yourself anymore? (I'll be doing another blog on "learned helplessness" which really sheds light on the behavioral aspects of this syndrome - including a discussion on "classical conditioning," think of the movie " A Clock Work Orange.")
There are many other things involved, e.g., escape plans, shelters, money issues, etc. Restraining orders have mixed reviews and most are not positive. I could write several blogs on these issues but that is not my focus here.
What exactly can a minister do? Please do not do marriage counseling. The Lord does not want his children being abused! The first responsible thing to do is to get the best treatment available. Refer them to people who are trained to handle these situations; specialists who are Christian if possible. If it is a small community and there are no other specialists available, or if it is a situation where there just is no money available, or there is a long waiting list, the minister may have to see them separately.
Read everything you can on domestic violence. Get a mentor who will help you if that is possible. Pray for guidance from God before every session - do not miss - the Holy Spirit is ready and willing to help you. (Clinical psychologists do not give directives to patients - that means that if the patient is competent to make decisions - the patient is the one who makes the final decision to stay or leave. If the patient is incompetent, i.e., is so confused and brain washed that she is not capable of protecting herself or her children, then escape plans, women's shelter, police protection, etc. may be in order.) The women who are killed by the man who "loves them" die within the first few days of leaving. You must be extremely careful.
Can an abuser change? The answer is yes. Can a marriage be restored? Yes. Can God work miracles? Yes. (If the abuser is antisocial - i.e., a psychopath, the odds are very, very slim for change and only God can save them. If the abuser is a narcissist, the odds are also slim as they do not have the capacity for love.)
In regards to the woman's point of view. If you have children, your first priority is to protect them. Research reveals that children and animals can be in danger also. You have to make the right decision which will affect your entire life and also your children if you have children. Remember, you are not yourself. You have changed. You will be suffering from multiple traumas. Most likely you will be suffering from "learned helplessness." You are confused as to what is the right thing to do. You need an anchor. Who is that anchor? Is it God? Does He hear you? Is it a friend? Is it a competent therapist? You absolutely must get help. It is not
going to get better no matter what the abuser tells you. Something has to change and it has to change now!
If you can find an experienced, caring, and competent Christian therapist, everything is eventually going to be ok. (Please be aware that there are many therapists out there who advertise themselves as Christian therapists to get clients - but they have no credentials- ask them what seminary or Bible College they went to - if none - be very careful.)
In regards to the man's point of view. There are men who do want to change but do not know how to do it. They just do not have the tools to deal with stress and earlier traumas in their lives. These men can change and with the right guidance they will. Marital therapy can then be continued.
Luke 4:18, is everything that I try to pattern myself after, and perhaps you can also:
"The Spirit of the Lord is upon Me, because He has anointed Me to preach the gospel to the poor; He has sent Me to heal the brokenhearted, to proclaim liberty to the captives and recovery of sight to the blind, to set at liberty those who are oppressed."
Luke 4:18: NKJV
No comments:
Post a Comment